Do You Carry Your Child’s School Bag?
Parenting January 4th, 2012I understand that all parents love their children and would do almost anything to let their children have that extra comfort. My question is, for how long?
There is a line drawn between over-protective and abusive.
I believe in training the child to be responsible for their own things and being independent the moment the child shows signs that he or she is able to handle the responsibilities.
My boys has been fully trained to bathe themselves, brush teeth for themselves, dress themselves when they were as young as three. Now, they wash their own plates and bowls. I continue to believe that it is crucial for the child to learn to be independent when they are ready.
For the whole of last year, I see this family EVERY DAY. An approximately 70 year old granny, a mother who looks like in her late 30s and a daughter whose ‘sides’ were bigger than mine and was slightly shorter than me, i.e. 158cm.
Over hearing their conversation many times and looking at her size, I suspected that she was a Primary 6 student.
Every morning her granny would carry her school bag and walk many steps ahead of the mother and daughter, who would usually be lagging behind holding hands, chit-chatting and laughing away.
Her granny’s hunch was pretty bad already even without any weight on her back.
How could the daughter and the grand-daughter add such unnecessary pressure on her spine?!
Whenever I see them, I would always be struggling within myself and holding myself back from asking, “You are such a big girl already, why are you not carrying your own bag and taking responsibilityof your own things?”
What puzzled me even more was the fact that she loves her granny! I have seen her kissed her granny on different occasions at the school gate before the old lady hand the heavy school bag over to her grand-daughter.
If you love your granny so much, why are you allowing her old body to go through this torture?
Even if your granny insists on carrying your school bag, you should be sensible enough to reject the offer and carry your own bag!
Well, its been two days since school reopened and I have yet to see the trio. If my suspicion was correct, she WAS a Primary 6 pupil and had moved on to Secondary School already, then that explains why I do not see her anymore.
The only time I carried my child’s school bag was when I need him to run faster to beat the traffic lights. Only then will I carry his school bag, dash across the traffic junction while holding his hands and return the heavy school bag to him immediately, when we reach the other end of the road. Other than that, NO way will I carry his bag for him!
January 4th, 2012 at 6:59 pm
Im quite shocked the girl is so tall. Maybe heavy bags inhibit growth? Haha u wanna try carry bag for Keat so he can shoot up? After shoot up Liao then pass the bag back to him. Lol
January 6th, 2012 at 10:06 am
I find it amazing how some parents pamper their children, to the child’s determinant, as you pointed out. This young girl should be carrying her own bag, does she think she is a princess? Children who are continually pampered often grow up to be misbehaved adults who believe it is their rate to be treated a certain way.
SmalltownRN´s last blog post ..Appropriate Care in the Appropriate setting….fact or fiction?
January 6th, 2012 at 2:50 pm
my son just started primary 1 this year and since we are working, his grandma brought him to school and fetch him daily.
I am also facing this school bag issue. I personally would like my son to carry his own bag but his grandma insist on carrying it for him especially when we are not around to stop it.
I already told my son to carry his own bag and my mil not to help him with it. However, I dont think its going to be of any effect.
January 7th, 2012 at 12:09 am
Hi Alex,
I can totally understand how it feels when the old folks INSIST on doing something for their beloved grandchild. It can be a rather knotty issue sometimes.
What made me put up this blog post is the topic of “When will adults learn to let go, so that the child can be independent?”
As of this post, the girl is so big already. There is no reason or excuse for the girl not to carry her own bag and allow the granny to carry for her…
As for P1, I can understand that sometimes, the bag can appear to be ‘bigger’ than the kid. *giggle* And that breaks the heart of most parents or grandparents, hence they would want to carry the heavy bag on behalf of the child…
January 9th, 2012 at 8:30 am
AGREE 100%!
blessed mum´s last blog post ..Ryan @ 31 months
January 14th, 2012 at 8:14 am
i don’t! I believe of being independent. As a teacher, I told that to my students too.
kkf´s last blog post ..Our 4th school bag for Dash!